So today I thought I’d share my ketchup recipe. Just this last fall was the first time I made this and next year I will cook it more than I did last year. This batch turned out a little watery and not at all ketchup-like but the flavor is great and without any funky ingredients. It will be way better once it’s cooked more to reduce it to a ketchup-like consistency. I have adjusted the cooking times to reflect that but feel free to test it as you go by dropping a little on a plate to see how it holds up.
I know to a lot of people it seems tedious and unnecessary to make things like this when they’re so easily and cheaply bought at the store. While being cheaper when you buy large quantities of tomatoes – or grow your own – it’s also amazingly satisfying to have made your own ketchup. Who else can say that? Not to mention you don’t need to worry about the amount of sugar or corn syrup in the final product because you can adjust it how you want. You can also pick the ripest tomatoes and therefore not have to add as much sugar to make up the sweetness that should naturally be in the tomatoes. You don’t need to worry about added colors and preservatives. This is not something you have to wonder about where the ingredients came from which is a great feeling.
While I canned mine, if canning makes you nervous you can always freeze it in small quantities and thaw it as needed. It lasts in the fridge for quite a while after opened or thawed – I would say at least 2-3 weeks.
- 10 C chopped fresh tomatoes
- 1 large onion
- 1 cinnamon stick
- 3 cloves garlic
- 1 tsp whole cloves
- 1 cup apple cider vinegar
- 3 tbsp dark brown sugar
- 1 1/4 tsp salt
- 1/2 tsp dry mustard powder
- 2 tsp paprika
- dash cayenne
- dash allspice
First peel your tomatoes. Have a boiling pot of water, slash a small X on the bottom of each tomato and drop into the boiling water for about 60 seconds. Remove and plunge into cold water and then the skins should easily peel off. If not, return to the boiling water for a few seconds. Chop roughly and simmer the tomatoes with the onion for 30 minutes. Blend together using an immersion blender(this will not remove the seeds) or put through a food mill. Put the whole spices, cinnamon, cloves and the garlic cloves into a pot with the vinegar. Simmer 30 minutes. Remove the spices.
Meanwhile, boil the tomatoes till reduced by half, stirring frequently. Add the spiced vinegar(I pour it through a strainer to remove the spices), brown sugar, salt, paprika, mustard powder, and all spice. Boil over medium high for 20 minutes till thickened.
To can, pour the mixture into sterilized jars leaving 1/4″ headspace. Put the lids on and process for 5 minutes in a boiling water bath. Should yield about 2-3 pints. I assume that you would be able to freeze this as well, making sure to cool completely before freezing, and stirring well after it’s thawed to mix back in any water that has separated.
I’ve served this on Mashed Potato Pancakes as in the pictures, and homemade hamburgers, veggie burgers, homemade fries. Anywhere you would use ketchup :)
Process and original recipe from Stocking Up by Carol Hupping Stoner under the title Catsup.